Share Your Insurance Details in 30 Seconds
Get a Quote
Carrier Directory | Trunnell Insurance Services
Policyholder Resources

Carrier Directory

Direct billing and claims contact numbers for every insurance carrier we work with. Bookmark this page — have these numbers ready before you need them.

30+ Carrier Relationships Updated 2026 Billing & Claims Direct Lines

Active Carriers

37 carriers
Carrier Billing Claims Notes
AllstatePersonal Lines (877) 810-2920 (877) 810-292024/7
American ModernSpecialty Personal (800) 543-2644 (800) 375-207524/7
AmTrustCommercial / Workers' Comp (877) 528-7878 (888) 239-3909
Auto-OwnersPersonal & Commercial (800) 288-8740M–F 8am–4:30pm (888) 252-462624/7 After-Hours Contact Agent First
Berkshire HathawaySee GUARD (below) for BHGUARD policies See GUARD row See GUARD row Agent-Directed
Bristol WestNon-Standard Auto (888) 888-008024/7 automated pay line (800) 274-7865M–F 8am–7pm ET
BriteCoJewelry & Watch Insurance (844) 727-4832 (844) 727-4832 Online Portal
ChubbPersonal & Commercial (800) 682-4822Personal (800) 372-4822Business (800) 252-467024/7
CNACommercial Lines (877) 276-7507 (877) 262-272724/7
EmployersWorkers' Compensation (888) 682-6671 (888) 682-667124/7
Erie InsurancePersonal & Commercial (800) 458-0811Opt. 5 for billing (800) 367-374324/7
ForemostSpecialty & Non-Standard (800) 527-3905 (800) 527-390724/7
GEICOPersonal Auto & Home (800) 861-3380 (800) 841-300024/7
Guard (BH GUARD)Berkshire Hathaway GUARD — Commercial (800) 673-2465 (888) 639-256724/7
HagertyClassic & Collector Vehicle (877) 922-9701 (877) 922-970124/7
Hartford, ThePersonal & Commercial (860) 547-5000 (800) 243-586024/7
Homeowners of AmericaPersonal Lines / Homeowners (833) 432-3455 (833) 432-3455 Online Portal Available
HoneycombCommercial Property / Multifamily (855) 866-1344 (855) 866-1344 Online-First
ISU SteadfastCommercial / Specialty Programs Contact your Trunnell agent Contact your Trunnell agent Agent-Directed
Liberty MutualPersonal & Commercial (800) 290-8711 (800) 225-246724/7
MarkelSpecialty Commercial (888) 642-4968 (800) 362-753524/7
Mercury InsurancePersonal Auto & Home (800) 503-3724 (800) 503-372424/7
National GeneralPersonal Lines (Allstate Company) (888) 293-5108 (800) 468-346624/7
NationwidePersonal & Commercial (877) 669-6877 (800) 848-633124/7
PalomarSpecialty: Earthquake, Flood, Hurricane (619) 567-5290 (800) 489-0105 Insured Portal Available
Personal Umbrella — Not a carrier; describes a coverage type. Umbrella policies are written through multiple carriers above (Travelers, Nationwide, Liberty Mutual, etc.). Contact your Trunnell agent to identify your specific umbrella carrier.
Pie InsuranceWorkers' Compensation (855) 705-2716 (844) 581-082824/7
Progressive (FAO Auto)Personal Auto (800) 776-4737 (800) 274-449924/7
Progressive FloodFlood Insurance (800) 776-4737 (800) 804-3452Flood claims line
SafecoPersonal Lines (Liberty Mutual Company) (800) 332-3226 (800) 332-322624/7
SelectivePersonal & Commercial (866) 332-6482 (866) 455-996924/7
SteadilyLandlord / Rental Property (888) 966-1611M–F 7am–7pm CT (888) 966-1611 Online Claims Portal
TravelersPersonal & Commercial (800) 842-5075 (800) 252-463324/7
Trinity RiverSpecialty / E&S Lines Contact your Trunnell agent Contact your Trunnell agent Agent-Directed
United Fire Group (UFG)Commercial Lines (800) 637-6309M–F 7am–6:30pm CT (800) 343-913124/7
West BendPersonal & Commercial (The Silver Lining) (800) 236-5002M–F 7am–4:30pm CT (877) 922-524624/7

Inactive / Special Notes

3 carriers
Carrier Status Notes
AAAPersonal Lines Agent-Directed AAA is a club-based network — contact numbers vary by regional AAA club. Contact your Trunnell agent for the appropriate club number for your policy.
EncompassPersonal Lines Inactive No longer actively written. Existing policies handled through Allstate (parent company). Call Allstate at (877) 810-2920 for service on any active Encompass policy.
Nationwide (Personal Lines)Personal Lines — See active Nationwide row above Inactive Personal lines were wound down in select states. Commercial lines remain active — see the Nationwide row above. Contact your Trunnell agent for policy-level guidance.
Important Notice: Phone numbers are verified as of April 2026 and sourced directly from carrier websites. Numbers may change — always confirm with the number on your declarations page or billing statement. For claims, contact your Trunnell Insurance agent first at (630) 742-2851 whenever possible — we can help guide you through the process. After-hours claims should be reported directly to your carrier using the numbers above. Always call 911 first in an emergency.