(630) 947-7980

Call to speak to an insurance expert.

Why Your Insurance Advisor May Recommend Companies You’ve Never Heard Of

One of the most common questions we hear at Trunnell Insurance Services is:
“Why am I being quoted by an insurance company I’ve never heard of?”

It’s a fair question, and an important one. The short answer is this: our job is not to sell you the most recognizable name, but to recommend the best fit for your specific risk, operations, and long-term goa

You Trust Experts in Other Areas –  Insurance Should Be No Different

Think about your relationship with a financial advisor.

You don’t walk into their office with a list of stocks and tell them exactly what to buy. You rely on their expertise, market knowledge, and research to guide you toward the right investments based on your objectives and risk tolerance.

Insurance works the same way.

At Trunnell Insurance Services, we evaluate carriers the way a financial advisor evaluates investments, based on strength, performance, suitability, and long-term stability, not name recognition alone.

Why the “Big Name” Isn’t Always the Best Option

Many nationally advertised insurance companies are excellent, but they aren’t always the right fit for every business or individual. Large carriers often:

  • Have rigid underwriting guidelines

  • Avoid niche industries or unique risks

  • Charge higher premiums due to overhead and brand marketing

  • Offer less flexibility for growing or evolving businesses

Smaller or lesser-known carriers often specialize in certain industries or risk profiles and can provide:

  • More competitive pricing

  • Better coverage terms

  • Industry-specific endorsements

  • More responsive claims handling

How We Vet Insurance Companies You May Not Recognize

We would never recommend an insurance company unless we were confident it met strict standards. Every carrier we work with is carefully evaluated for:

  • Financial strength and stability (AM Best and similar ratings)

  • Claims reputation and responsiveness

  • Longevity in the marketplace

  • Industry specialization

  • Regulatory compliance

If a carrier didn’t meet these criteria, we wouldn’t put our clients, or our reputation, behind them.

Insurance Is Not One-Size-Fits-All

The goal of insurance isn’t to buy the most familiar logo — it’s to ensure you’re properly protected when something goes wrong.

We match carriers to clients based on:

  • Business size and industry

  • Risk exposure

  • Growth plans

  • Claims history

  • Budget considerations

Sometimes that match happens to be a well-known national carrier. Other times, it’s a company you haven’t seen advertised during a football game, but one that is far better suited for your specific needs.

Our Commitment to You

At Trunnell Insurance Services, we act as advisors first, not salespeople. If we recommend a company you don’t recognize, it’s because:

  • We believe it’s a strong, reliable carrier

  • The coverage fits your risk profile

  • It provides better value than the alternatives

  • We trust them to be there when you need them most

We wouldn’t recommend them if they weren’t a good fit.

If you ever have questions about a carrier we present, or want to understand why we’re recommending a particular option, we’re always happy to walk you through the reasoning. Transparency and trust are the foundation of everything we do.

We Work With Top Rated Insurers to Find the Best Policies

wheaton insurance

Wheaton Family Saves Big on Home, Auto, and Business Insurance

How Trunnell Insurance Services Helped the Balboa Family Save Big on Home, Auto, and Business Insurance When R. Balboa’s insurance premiums skyrocketed last year, he knew he needed to make a change. With a large household, multiple vehicles, and a thriving property management business, finding the right insurance policies was

Read More »

Home Insurance Premiums are Surging

Home Insurance Premiums Are Surging – A WSJ Article If you’re a homeowner or an insurance policyholder, you’ve likely noticed your home insurance premiums creeping up lately. According to an article by the Wall Street Journal, home insurance premiums have surged by an average of 20% over the past year,

Read More »

Family Saves on Home and Auto Insurance

How Trunnell Insurance Helped the Johnson Family Save on Home and Auto Insurance Meet the Johnson Family The Johnson family, a bustling household of five, lives in an upper-middle-class neighborhood. With both parents working full-time, their three children—ages 14, 17, and 18—have had to become quite self-sufficient, particularly when it

Read More »

Save on Business Insurance

How Trunnell Insurance Helped Smith Properties Slash Their Premiums by 20% Running a successful commercial property business comes with its fair share of challenges, and high insurance premiums can often be at the top of the list. Recently, Smith Properties, a well-known player in the commercial real estate industry, found

Read More »

Better Rates on Home and Auto Insurance

Success Story: How Trunnell Insurance Services Helped Randy C. Secure Better Rates on Home and Auto Insurance In the heart of Naperville, IL, Randy C. and his family have established a warm and vibrant home over the past 15 years. Living in a charming 40-year-old house with his wife and

Read More »

Have Your Insurance Premiums Gone Up

Have Your Insurance Premiums Gone Up? Here’s Why and What You Can Do About It Navigating the world of insurance is no small task, especially when you open your renewal notice only to find that your premiums have gone up—again. If you’re a homeowner or vehicle owner who has recently

Read More »